There are very few things in the world that is either right or wrong. Most things have certain elements that are right and certain elements that are wrong. Butcher block countertops have several advantages, which are also the reasons why people like to buy them. At the same time, there are some serious concerns or disadvantages that have to be considered as well.
While your personal preference and setting of your kitchen will always come into play, you do have to consider the butcher block countertops pros and cons before you decide to buy them. Don’t run into a hasty inference. Check out the arguments in favor and against of the countertops and make a pragmatic choice.
Butcher Block Countertops Pros
1. Butcher block countertops have a very pleasant appearance. They add a great deal of aesthetic value to the setting. They look elegant and they look and feel warm. There are harder countertop choices out there but most of those materials lack aesthetics and they certainly don’t feel warm. Try to touch a stone countertop on a mildly cold day and you would know how cold they are. Touch a butcher block countertop on one of the coldest days in the year and they would still feel a little warm and welcoming. Anyone who likes a good looking kitchen would want to have a neatly crafted butcher block, just for the visual appeal if that is all there is to benefit from.
2. Countertops are not just there for their visual appeal. They have to be utilitarian. You will use it for cutting a host of various foods and packages. A butcher block countertop will always offer you a strong enough foundation to cut almost anything. You don’t have to be a chef to deserve such a countertop. Also, even if you have never cooked a wholesome meal, you would still enjoy using a butcher block countertop while cutting anything.
3. Butcher block countertops can be refinished. In other words, the topmost surface can be redone. You cannot renew the surfaces of quartz or granite. Once they have been dealt many a blows, they are done. Although it is true that most countertops last for decades, the luxury to refinish the surface of butcher block countertops with a bit of sanding and applying some mineral oil is certainly something worth mentioning.
4. Butcher block countertops can be installed by any homeowner or family member. You don’t have to be a master installer of countertops, you don’t need to hire anyone and you certainly don’t have to pay any installation charges. All you do is buy one and set it up all by yourself. You might need to be a little handy with do it yourself projects or with handheld tools but that is not really a challenge.
5. You can also make your butcher block countertops should you want to have a more challenging adventure. You can also save some money by avoiding retail prices of readymade countertops. However, not everyone can come up with a solid piece without any professional help. You will have to be deft with woodworking to make a worthwhile butcher block countertop.
Butcher Block Countertops Cons
1. The biggest disadvantage of butcher block countertops is the fact that wood is not a friend of water, or vice versa. You cannot imagine your countertop being kept away from water. You will spill water on countertops, the countertop itself will have to be washed and when these happen, your butcher block countertop will get damaged. When it is new, you may not notice much of an impact but as the wood gets more exposed to water and repeatedly, it would deteriorate. From the aesthetics to the physical integrity, everything in butcher block countertops would be threatened upon exposure to water.
2. Butcher block countertops are vulnerable to stains. Unlike some other materials which get an additional coating to prevent the countertops from being stained, butcher block countertops are exposed. Spilling liquids or food that can leave behind rigid stains will end up damaging your beautiful butcher block set piece. You can try to clean the stains as and when they develop. But it is not possible to be that reactive or proactive all the time.
3. While there are pros and cons of most materials used for countertops, none have the problem of expansion and contraction as well as warping. Butcher block countertops will warp over time, especially when exposed to a lot of water. They can grasp moisture and the wood will certainly expand and contract given the temperatures and the seasons throughout the year.
4. Butcher block countertops require frequent maintenance when used extensively. If you are not someone who cuts food or prepares food on the counter, then you don’t have to worry about this but if you do use the countertop extensively, then you will have to oil the surface time and again.