7 Key Pros and Cons of Equal Rights Amendment

7 Key Pros and Cons of Equal Rights Amendment

by / Comments Off / 7687 View / Feb 11, 2015

The Equal Rights Amendment was one of the changes made to the original United States Constitution. This amendment was first introduced in 1923, but it did not pass through the House of Congress until 1979. This amendment was designed to make gender equality a constitutional right. In basic terms it meant that men and women should have access to the same rights and freedoms. Evaluating this amendment is always unique based upon your perspective. In order to gain a full view of the Equal Rights Amendment, it is important that you understand the context and are aware of both the pros and cons.

Pros of the Equal Rights Amendment

The positives of the Equal Rights Amendment seem pretty self-explanatory. However, they are even more far reaching than you might consider. These benefits have a huge impact on the society that we live in.

1. Legal Impact
With gender equality being made an amendment to the constitution, it would then be illegal for any favoritism or prejudice to be shown based on gender. Having this into law would make gender equality possible and would make gender discrimination less prevalent. Keeping people from holding specific views is almost impossible, but it possible to make legal repercussions for those that act against the law.

2. Rights Made For All
It is only the Equal Rights Amendment that makes it a legal right for civil, human and diplomatic rights for all. Thee rights are not generally protected under just the constitution for all genders, but are only made equal for all citizens through the Equal Rights Amendment.

3. Court Precedence
Another huge advantage of the Equal Rights Amendment is that a clearer legal standard for court rulings on gender discrimination was set. This means that all forms of gender discrimination would not be tolerated and that legal rulings would be made with a set standard in mind. Before the Equal rights amendment there was no court precedence for ruling on gender discrimination cases.

4. Rights Recognized as Legal
The biggest benefit of the Equal Rights Amendment is that it ended the discussion or debate of gender equality. It was finally recognized by law that both men and women were equal for the first time. This means that women no longer had to fight for their standing in society and were finally on level footing with men.

Cons of the Equal Rights Amendment

Although many see the Equal Rights Amendment as transformative and n necessary on all levels, there are a few negatives that can be pointed out about this amendment.

1. Tricky Language
Most of the downsides to eth Equal Rights Amendment can be traced to the tricky language that was used to write it. This means that the amendment is not written clearly and there is some room for interpretation, which can lead to confusion and lack of gender equality. Many of those that opposed the amendment argued that it took away some rights from women and from the masses.

2. Amendment That Breeds Confusion
Others felt that the Equal Rights Amendment was not a good change to the constitution because it was confusing and could lay the framework for changing the way that laws were made. This was a worry that many people felt at the time that the Equal Rights amendment was introduced.

3. Final Verdict
No matter what side of the argument you fall, it is hard to ignore the overriding positives that come from the Equal Rights Amendment. It is hard to believe that a time in history ever existed when women were not granted the basic rights that men possessed. Gender equality has come a long way in a rather short period of time, but still has further strides to make.

Context of Equal Rights Amendment

When the amendment was first introduced some were opposed and others were strongly in its favor. The influence of activism was what many felt made this a polarizing issue. The context of the amendment is important when you are determining if this change to the constitution was necessary and progressive to society. This amendment makes it clear that fairness of rights under law should not be denied by the United States. It also makes the mandate that Congress does not have the ability or control to make changes to this amendment.

Was The Amendment Viewed Positively?

It seems as though there were differing opinions on the topic of equal rights and this amendment was a bit controversial at first. Some felt that gender inequality was not necessary, but others felt that it was a god given right and should not be denied. This meant that two very passionate views on this topic existed. In order to decide if the Equal Rights Amendment made a difference, it is important to take a closer look at the pros and cons.